Montauk’s summer 2025 dining scene is sizzling with new debuts, revamped icons, and perennial favorites—all set against the backdrop of stunning Atlantic and bayfront views. Whether you’re seeking a lively social hub, a serene sunset dinner, or a stylish cocktail spot, Montauk’s restaurants are ready to deliver memorable meals and high summer energy. Here’s your guide to the must-visit restaurants in Montauk this season.
Gigi’s Montauk at Gurney’s
290 Old Montauk Highway
Opening June 16, Gigi’s Montauk is the highly anticipated new flagship at Gurney’s Resort. Designed as a vibrant social hub, it features shareable plates, inventive coastal cocktails, and sweeping ocean views. Signature dishes include the Angry Lobster (1.5 lb lobster in a smoky, spicy sauce), Giant Shrimp Scampi, and a spicy Hamachi Gigi Sushi Roll. The space is expansive, with seating for 120 indoors and 110 on the patio—perfect for group gatherings or meeting new friends. Gigi’s is part of Gurney’s broader transformation, which also includes the new Dune Café & Lounge and a Dolce & Gabbana Beach Club takeover for a luxury beachside experience.
Mary Lou’s Montauk
474 West Lake Drive
This new restaurant and bar brings eclectic décor, a playful ‘70s and ‘80s vibe, and a menu of seasonal, locally sourced fare. Expect Wagyu burgers, caviar towers, prime cuts, and fresh seafood, all served in a space adorned with lush textures and striking art. With roots in Palm Beach, Mary Lou’s is poised to become a Montauk nightlife and dining hotspot, focusing on strong cocktails, small plates, and a lively atmosphere that encourages dancing late into the night.
Ocean Club at Montauk Yacht Club
32 Star Island Road
The Montauk Yacht Club’s Ocean Club is officially open for the season, offering wood-fired fare, fresh seafood, and a raw bar in a stylish, relaxed setting. Chef Jarad McCarrol brings a taste of St. Barths to Montauk, with a menu that matches the breezy, vacation vibes. Don’t miss the wood-fired pizza and cocktails by the pool, perfect for a summer afternoon or sunset dinner.
Ruschmeyer’s Beach Grill
161 Second House Road
A beloved Montauk icon, Ruschmeyer’s has relaunched with a fresh coastal menu and a lively, camp-inspired atmosphere. Expect dishes like monkfish tail au poivre and lobster spaghetti, plus pizza pop-ups and curated experiences that keep the party going well after dark. The venue’s blend of nostalgia and modern flair makes it a favorite for both locals and visitors.
Mavericks Montauk
51 S Edgemere Street
Overlooking Fort Pond, Mavericks is Montauk’s go-to for surf-and-turf with a view. This upscale steakhouse, reopened for the 2025 season, features locally sourced meats and seafood, fine wines, and crafted cocktails. The sprawling dining room and outdoor seating make it ideal for sunset celebrations, special occasions, or a luxurious night out.
Duryea’s Montauk
65 Tuthill Road
A classic for over a century, Duryea’s offers chic, nautical outdoor waterfront dining with a menu centered on lobster, local fish, and a standout raw bar. The Lobster Cobb Salad is legendary (and shareable), and the sunset views from the deck are unbeatable. The market and boutique add to the experience, making Duryea’s a must-visit for both lunch and dinner.
Navy Beach
16 Navy Road
Navy Beach remains a Montauk staple, set right on the sand with panoramic bay views. The 2025 season brings new menu items like Shrimp Tempura Hand Rolls and Tuna Crudo Lettuce Wraps, plus classic favorites like Buttermilk Fried Chicken and Soy Glazed Halibut. The drink menu features new summer cocktails and spirit-free options, making it perfect for groups and families alike.
Bagatelle Montauk
500 West Lake Drive
Taking over the iconic Gosman’s location, Bagatelle brings French Mediterranean flair and festive brunches to Montauk. The international brand is known for its lively atmosphere, making it a top choice for those seeking a celebratory meal by the water.
The Crow’s Nest
4 Old West Lake Drive
Set on Lake Montauk, The Crow’s Nest is a local favorite for its beach bar, sunset views, and standout dishes like lobster pasta and whipped ricotta. The laid-back yet stylish vibe makes it an excellent choice for date nights or group dinners.
Tips for Dining in Montauk Summer 2025
Reservations: Essential at most hot spots, especially for indoor seating or large groups. Some, like Duryea’s, are first-come, first-served for outdoor tables.
Sunset Timing: Book early for the best sunset views at Navy Beach, Duryea’s, Mavericks, and The Crow’s Nest.
Dress Code: Montauk is casual-chic—think sundresses, linen shirts, and sandals.
Group Dining: Many restaurants offer family-style or shareable plates, making them ideal for groups.
Montauk’s 2025 summer restaurants are serving up more than just great food—they’re offering unforgettable experiences by the sea. Whether you’re after a glamorous night out, a laid-back lunch, or a sunset dinner with friends, these hot spots are ready to make your summer sizzle.
At One Haus, we understand the unique challenges and opportunities within the hospitality industry. Our team of experienced recruiters specializes in connecting restaurants and hotels with top-tier talent tailored to your specific needs. Whether you’re looking to fill high-demand roles, overcome seasonal hiring challenges, or find professionals with specialized skills, we’re here to help.
As you navigate your path in this competitive industry, consider partnering with One Haus, a leader in hospitality recruitment. Contact us today to find out how we can connect you with opportunities in these top cities and beyond.
For hospitality businesses partnering with One Haus, you gain access to an extensive network of hospitality professionals, industry expertise, and a personalized approach to recruitment. Let us handle the complexities of hiring so you can focus on delivering exceptional experiences to your guests. Contact One Haus today to discover how we can elevate your team and support your business goals.